This post should serve politics teachers in preparing lessons. It compares the promises before the election with the coalition agreement negotiated compromises in the synopsis. Based on the press review can work out the role cards for a talk show or panel discussion.
Background: The coalition agreement, decide the parliamentary groups, which together have a majority in parliament and form a joint coalition for the Federal Government be. The coalition agreement is enshrined in the medium to long-term cooperation of the coalition during the upcoming legislative term in a message index. The parties agree by contract is human and material conditions under which they are willing to jointly enter into a coalition.
In three rounds was deliberated the issue of health. sat in a working group of health professionals of the parties. In the great round of negotiations, in which not only were experts and between the three party leaders of the CDU, CSU and FDP. The main result is: "At the beginning of the legislature, a government commission is used
.
Synopsis coalition agreement on health
Gabriel and practice Nahles sharp criticism of the coalition agreement
The designated SPD chairman, Sigmar Gabriel, the coalition agreement between the black and yellow criticized sharply, CDU and FDP were acting "against the public good," Gabriel said after a party meeting in Hanover. The plans of the government parties were "not financially viable". Criticism also came from the designated new SPD General Secretary Andrea Nahles and SPD parliamentary leader Frank-Walter Steinmeier. Particularly sharp Gabriel
attacked the plans in health policy. Costs and risks of health and care insurance would be borne solely on the shoulders of workers, said the designated party leader. Worse still was the fact that the "specious" "Brought the health system as a function of operations and cash position of finance minister" of a fair funding of the taxpayer, he said. The insured will see that the benefits "are not addressed by what they do but what does the Minister of Finance may make available," warned Gabriel. Merkel has done so before the election, as if the so-called capitation fee from the table and thus misled the voters.
Source: http://www.n24.de
unions see the end of solidarity
expected sharp the coalition agreement was criticized by the opposition and the unions. "Our fears have come true in many cases", said the head of the DGB, Michael Sommer, the New Press ". "Especially in health care and I see an end to solidarity, here it is with black and bitter cold yellow." The coalition agreement stands for redistribution at the expense of ordinary people and for the benefit of the company, Sommer said. If the health care reform to be implemented as planned, "are programmed social conflicts", he warned of protests and mass demonstrations. Source: http://www.tagesschau.de
GOOD SIGNAL ON INDUSTRY LOCATION GERMANY
... Many industries such as chemical companies and car makers evaluated the coalition agreement as a positive course for the industry in Germany. Stand there in it some remarkable, which could certainly help the economy, said the head of the Darmstadt pharmaceutical and specialty chemicals group Merck, Karl-Ludwig Kley. BDA President Dieter Hundt had welcomed earlier, that employers are exempt in future from rising health care costs. "It is very rightly emphasized in the new coalition agreement that the health care market is the most important growth and employment sector in Germany," said the head of the Stuttgart pharmaceutical distributor Celesio, Fritz Oesterle, to Reuters: "I take it that gets under the new government the responsibility of the individual for his health is more important."
Source: http://de.reuters.com
The Times: Bluem: "Black-yellow ghost drivers" in health care and
By Norbert Bluem Man can make sense of loss. One must not. The capitation was bathing the CDU in the Bundestag election in 2005. 2009, after the election, they tried it again with the income-independent Contribution to health insurance, for all should be equal in height. When the boss pays the same contribution to health insurance as his chauffeur and the master the same as the janitor, you do not Plato, Aristotle and Kant have read in order to keep that unfair. There is enough common sense. It shall be for such cases since ancient times, the rule of thumb: "different treatment for same equal and unequal." The capitation treated equally unequal. The capitation fee is the same amount of money to be applied, which has been purchased with the income-proportional premiums for health insurance. The capitation fee is like an average rule, the average is created by some more, others pay less. More pay those who earn less, pay less and those who earn more. This is the logic of capitation. Six points can be noted as its result, and they fall out all negative.
First, the capitation is a blow against justice. The social balance that previously had health insurance internally using the income-proportional contribution of existence is now to be organized by the tax office. The low-income policyholders will receive a government grant towards their capitation.
Second, the capitation raises more state and transfer. Above the income limits to the government subsidy paid, it stays with the leveling effect of the capitation, which sheared off all the income gap with the same brush. The average income to pay the bill. They were supposed to be relieved of the tax reform in particular.
Third, the financing of the tax-funded grant is contrary to the objectives of tax reform. In determining the need for subsidy, the wage level can not be the only criterion. A part-time working millionaire would otherwise declared a grant beneficiaries. So, all income levels, the beneficiary will be scrolls. Greetings from Hartz IV. The welfare state Mendelt so for general needs test facility.
Fourth, the capitation more bureaucracy in the wake. The employer share of the cost of health insurance is to be frozen. So the employees pay all future increases in costs alone. Employers are released from the effort to curb health costs. The Confederation of Employers' Associations can be its member pharmaceutical industry of the chain. The development of health care costs, employers now no longer interested.
Fifth: The commit the employer's contribution reduces the pressure on cost reduction. The joint financing of social security and self-government were the school of social partnership. In her the balance of interests between workers and employers trained. After the Riester pension slow exit from the joint responsibility of social partners will continue for the welfare state. The following health care insurance. Long term care insurance is to be supplemented by a funded private supplementary liability insurance, which will only be paid by the employees.
Sixth, the social partnership is slowly but steadily made flat. At the end of the pathway is the alliance of the nationalization and the privatization. Some need the other. The nationalization of the need to privatize because they do not solve the problem of a relative living standard backup. The privatization depend on nationalization, because they have no answer to the problem of poverty. Poverty is in fact a business.
Seventh: capitation and its consequences in a different welfare state. On the line is the subsidiary of solidarity, as in a reciprocal in nature and is rooted with Equity-appointed Social Security. A reform of the welfare state would need to more state-free, self-managed aim solidarity. The opposite is the case. The ghost riders have right of way. Capitation or citizen insurance - what this dispute is the question: "How the health insurance comes to the money of the people?" It should not be the meaning and The purpose of health insurance in mind: healing the sick! And where are the boundaries of solidarity? Health insurance is not responsible for anything that impairs the well-being.
Source: http://www.tagesspiegel.de
Hoppe: coalition agreement provides an opportunity for a new health culture
The recent results of the coalition negotiations CDU and FDP on health said the president of the Federal Medical Association, Prof. Dr. Jörg-Dietrich Hoppe: "The draft a coalition agreement provides the opportunity to build a new health culture in Germany. If the insured back to the patients and doctors can be doctors again, then the proper course is taken. Cutting red tape and no further commercialization of health care has become the new government set a goal that is right and important, so from a bureaucratised health system is again a human health care.
The draft coalition agreement promises to align the health care structures to a long life society out. This gives hope that health policies do not stay longer saving medical services policy is, but that medical advances and demographic changes are accepted as realities.
The health system should be made liberal, patients should be given more choice of doctors and the freelancer is to be established once again. However, the words must now be followed by deeds. The doctors in Germany are willing to contribute to this effect to the design of health care "
source. http://www.bundesaerztekammer.de
0 comments:
Post a Comment