I. decision process
Aims and key points of the reform
III. Press review on the reform
IV outlines the social insurance principle
V. Links to the opinions of the lobby groups
I. decision process
agreements between the CDU / CSU and SPD in the coalition agreement
The coalition agreement between CDU / CSU and SPD was clearly states that "The parties have different approaches developed, the" solidarity health premium "(CDU and CSU) and the" citizens' insurance "(SPD), which can not be reconciled easily with each other. We want for this question in the course of 2006 develop a solution together. "
After months of sometimes difficult negotiations on 2 February 2007, the health reform by the German Bundestag ( Printed Matter 16/3100 ) adopted. Yes with 378 parliamentarians voted. 23 representatives of the CDU / CSU and the SPD have 20 deputies voted in opposition as well as the negative. The Federal Council on 16 Approved in February. Federal President Köhler on 26 March, the law was signed. The changes are mostly on 1 April 2007 entered into force.
II objectives and key points
• Improving the financial basis of the statutory health insurance
• for all
• Access to medical progress, irrespective of the individual performance of the insured
• More choice for the insured
• competition between the insurers for the best medical care for the insured
• Fair competition for cash
• Targeted use of funds in the health system
• competition in the private system (PHI) system
Accordingly, "developed for the field of public health insurance in 2006, a comprehensive concept for the future is also applied to keeping the contributions to health insurance at least stable and most to reduce. "
agreed in detail, the Parties agree that the health system should receive in relation to the interaction of private health insurance and public health insurance funds increasingly competitive orientation.
The rates of health insurance to be raised in 2007 by about 0.5 percentage points It is expected additional revenue of about € 5 billion. The contribution rate increase will be equal, half each, worn by workers and employers. The average premium of all insurance is taken on 14.7% of gross salary. Of this, 6.9 percentage points paid by the employer. The employee contribution introduced in 2005 still contains the special contribution of 0.9% and will therefore be on average 7.8 percentage points.
The tax-funded subsidy for health insurance in 2008 will be 1.5 billion euros. For 2009 are estimated at € 4 billion. Long term, the tax subsidy should continue to max. € 14 billion increase in the year. Through him, the future is to be contributory co-insurance of children in the health insurance, and other contributory benefits such as maternity pay, etc. various services during pregnancy funded.
The wage-based contributions from employers and workers and the subsidy from tax revenues will in future be distributed to health insurance through a health fund. This is a Additional complementary contribution that the health insurance companies can collect directly from their respective policyholders. Here they are free to raise this additional contribution to percentage of income or as a capitation. The additional contribution will not exceed 1% of the income limits of the insured. Cash, spend less than they receive funds from the health fund, its members instead reimburse contributions. (See chart Fund) This means that cash received on account of their insured structure and economical led administration the opportunity to provide rebates. The aim of the competition among health insurance funds should be strengthened.
The legally prescribed Contribution rate is then increased by a politically supported decision if the expenditure of funds shall not be financed at least 95 percent from the Health Fund. The tax subsidies are included here.
additional services by the reform:
The range of statutory health insurance has been extended through reimbursement eg:
• Mother or father-child treatments, provided they are considered medically necessary and are prescribed by a doctor
• vaccinations, the Permanent Vaccination Commission (STIKO)
• rehabilitation
recommends also support the national health insurance, the "Specialized outpatient palliative care," this allows the dying and seriously ill people to live in dignity and with as little pain and die.
compulsory insurance with effect from 1 April 2007 should have health insurance or re-assured all the people who had previously never even have health insurance or have lost their health insurance. So far about 200,000 people were without health insurance in Germany. Mandatory insurance for all Germans agreed. Persons who were last at a private health insurance company can, thus facilitating the return to conditions in their private health insurance. You are required to be by 1 January, 2009 privately insured. You can then choose between a full rate of medical expenses or the newly introduced base rate that is comparable with the performance of SHI. Private insurance companies may not reject the contract in the base rate or risk premiums rise or exclusion of benefits agreed.
The limitation of doctors to pay a fixed total budget is repealed. Instead, the compensation will be changed to flat rates per service, per illness or per patient treated, which are defined in a uniform national Euro-tariff. Priority will be compensation for complexes are of related services. In the case of violations of certain amounts of power while a physician only gradually lower (off echelon) prices must be calculated.
The pharmacist must pay a higher discount of 2.30 €, € 2 so far, the statutory health insurance funds. This represents a saving of around 180 million € annually. That is, the pharmacist will earn only 5.80 instead of € 6:10 € plus 3% per ceded prescription drug.
In private health insurance (PHI) are insured with a change of insurance in future retirement provisions, which were formed during the previous insurance for them, the new insurance can take. So far, losing the insured persons in the private health insurance premiums from their built capital stocks, if they switch to another insurance company.
performance limitations
addition to the expansion of services were also agreed line cuts in the statutory health insurance. These can include the limitations of benefits for treatment, arising out of non-medically necessary procedures, tattooing, piercing and so on. The costs must be patient, the patient who now own. Higher costs may also arise when screening tests are not perceived, and later diagnosed with a chronic illness is. The doctors and doctors may, from 1 January 2008, only still in a "therapiegerechtem behavior," including participation in screening is one issue, the annual certification for the chronically ill. This is necessary in order to limit the health insurance contribution by the insured to the maximum one percent of income.
III. Press review on the reform
04/02/2007 Welt am Sonntag, page 13: "The fund blends two models that are incompatible: the citizens of the SPD and the health insurance package for the CDU. The parties have just tortured to compromise because he has the option of later switching to their whole system. The result is a law that can hardly understand a citizen really is. Devastating, however, the impression that this is also true for most MPs. "
04/02/2007 Sunday newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, page 43:" Change is not for patients and insured once more. Health Minister Ulla Schmidt (SPD) and her colleagues know that bureaucratic red tape creations such as the planned health fund can not be introduced overnight. All that is sensitive, has the Minister's why even put on the back bench. The new government collecting money, health funds, will come only in 2009, the new fee schedule for physicians even before 2011. Opponents of the Reform, and the MPs who voted despite major concerns now under pressure from their tour with Yes hope so, that Schmidt's plans at the end but not a reality. "
02.03.2007 Süddeutsche Zeitung, Munich, page 4:" From the Law can say little good. It is in many ways the opposite of what Union and the SPD have always demanded. They wanted to reduce fees in order to reduce the cost of jobs. Now rates are rising - and strong. They wanted more competition, but now there is a uniform amount. They wanted to secure the base of the cash, now is weakening their foundation, because nobody knows what the future holds and how the state of his billions wants to raise the cash. Certainly not all bad. For people without health situation will improve, even for patients who want to die at home. The reform is: A bad apple is rotten, even if some points edible. But why has achieved so little? "
02.02.2007 daily newspaper, page 4:" Political reform is a success: Finally, the grand coalition of two diametrically opposite concepts zusammengeklaubt a compromise. Technically the result is considered a failure. "No problem solved, but new created" taken by the Chief of the Scientific Institute of Local Health Insurance, Klaus Jacobs together.
... In the spring and summer months the last year is being negotiated, but neither of the two approaches convinces the other side. Then parliamentary leader Volker Kauder Union can drop the term "health fund. Soon discuss all of these politicians to collecting money. Finally, it sets Minister Ulla Schmidt from the weary professional politicians negotiating a compromise. The genius part is that the fund be converted depending on your taste for public insurance or capitation can. Now move the two sides at pruning the fund as a lowest common denominator.
From the super agency, the articles states, collects and distributes, the fund is shrinking so fast the virtual institution. To install it in 2009, are exactly three additional Staff needed. Otherwise, everyone keeps their job: Cash drag a review, the Federal Insurance Office to be distributed as between the plans, that these are not sicker members at a disadvantage. What is new is that the fund levy from 2009 single contributions, the state will subsidize the whole year with up to 14 billion euros.
pay Otherwise the same people as before, health care, above all the employees. "The goal of sustainability was not achieved smoothly," said the economist Ulrich. Unknown is also where the Treasury will reap the tax subsidies for health care and how the revenue sharing between the 250 health insurance should look like. The money is certainly not enough from the beginning, predicts health scientist Jacob and warns of one per cent case. Funds that do not with the unit contributions may raise additional contributions from 2009, namely a maximum of one percent of gross income. "Cash with many low-income members will be relatively quick end," said the scientist. "
IV outlines the social insurance principle
With the adoption of Bismarck's social legislation, the end of the 19th Century is historically the basic decision like for a social policy, the financing and providing benefits to the closely-related Employment is bound. The controls since that time dominating principle of insurance or actuarial equivalence principle, that to safeguard against social risks such as illness, injury, old age and unemployment contributions paid in the case of a risk occurrence will be paid benefits to policyholders. Thus, states that the unpredictable occurrence of a risk to individuals and are difficult to predict the resources required for the solidarity can be calculated. The equivalence principle in which they are entitled to the granting of benefits in the amount of the payments will come, but by the principle of solidarity - the strong help the weak, but weakened to bear. The orientation of social solidarity can, in contrast to private insurance in principle to any risks or exclusions.
The following features are characteristic of the social security system:
• Insurance •
equivalence principle
• coupling to the employment
• parity contribution from employers and employees, except for the dentures
• Liability of the state finance problems.
Legal framework of the welfare state aimed
The German welfare state principle as a constitutional principle in Article 20 and Article 28 GG, especially in the manufacture and provision of so-called tolerable living conditions, social Security, social equality and social justice. The basic conditions provide the framework conditions for the political development of the welfare state.
also require the state to the goal of social equality has contributed to the shaping of the modern welfare state has created a distribution and redistribution of state.
The financing base of social insurance and in particular the statutory health insurance has been suffering from the eighties to a weak growth. The PAYG social security systems are in a difficult situation. The following factors have led to high entry loads:
• Declining fertility rates,
• extended training periods,
• a late entry into professional life,
• the growing medical and medical progress,
• a welcome increase in life expectancy,
• the changing nature of work in particular economic, employment structure (meaning the loss of "normal working relationship" with the increase of part-time, minor employment, new self through I-AG, etc.) and even high unemployment.
So is the balance between revenue and expenditure of the institution, but also come from government regulation and personal discretion of proportion. At the same time Germany has to face intense competition in the world of globalization. The related financial burdens are viewed by employers as a threat to international competitiveness, because the benefits are financed by contributions to leading principally of the "Bismarck model". This compares to the recipients, the raise of their contributions such as the pension entitlement to payments equivalent.
The growing demographic imbalance, so the mismatch between increasingly more and more contributors and beneficiaries pointed to the situation. On behalf of the insured is often criticized that despite increasing contribution burdens tend to fall in services, such as in the form of higher co-payments or mutilation of the services provided by statutory health insurance reported.
The trade-offs between social protection on the one hand and economic performance and thus increased employment on the other.
are applicable to the policy in this situation, only three possibilities: extensive absence of social benefits and rules, which separates However, due to immense damage. This leaves only two alternatives: "If the benefits of social policy will continue to take advantage, must have its high price that is high or avoidable even increasing taxes and social acceptance. Those who argue for cost recovery reforms of the welfare state, must take a significant reduction of benefits in purchasing. "
V. Links to the opinions of the lobby groups
www.bundestag.de/ausschuesse/a14/
anhoerungen/029 -034/stllg_ref_entw/index.html
www.bundestag.de/ausschuesse/a14/
anhoerungen/029-34/stllg_nicht_eingel/index.html
www.die-gesundheitsreform.de/index.html
www.bmg . bund.de