Thursday, October 9, 2008

Where Are All The Good Pokemon Heart Gold Roms?

discussion on the commuter tax / traveling allowance - information for teachers


The information is appropriate to treat the institution of the Federal Constitutional Court in connection with proposals on tax policy issue at the German Bundestag in the classroom.

first The traveling allowance under the old law
second Reasons for the abolition of the government coalition CDU / CSU and SPD
third Situation of the commuters
4th As it is in other countries?
5th Legal situation - before the Federal Constitutional Court 6th
The discussion - Pros and Cons for travel to seventh
What next?


first The traveling allowance under the old law
used could be specified with the traveling allowance in their tax returns, expenses for trips between home and regular place of work. It did not matter what means of transport back down this path was and how high the costs were. An exception was air routes and routes with tax-free bus transportation. 4500 € in Year were sold up, and this limit was not stated if the roads were covered with a motor vehicle. This rule was changed to the Tax Amendment Act 2007 on 1.1.2007, at present, the Federal Constitutional Court has asked to review the legality of the new rules.

second Reasons for the abolition of the government coalition of CDU / CSU and SPD
The government justified the abolition of the former regime so that trips to and from work are caused as well as the choice of the place is usually private, and therefore as a so-called mixed expenses are considered. This reasoning applies since 1 January 2007 in Germany, as in other European countries also, the so-called "factory gate" principle. This rule states that what taxpayers for their business or profession not spend, may be taxed, but only the net income. In Germany, even under the new law a social policy for mitigating long-distance commuters in the form of tougher rules for trips home for the disabled.
With the new law also constitute a subsidy, an exception created. The professionals who have an "above average" long way to work, the so-called long-distance commuters, fall within the following exception: From the 21th kilometer for the journey from home to the permanent establishment are expenses for car or public transport journeys with a mileage allowance of 30 cents per mile settable down.
The loss compared with the previous regulation results in long-distance commuters fact that for the first 20 km of the commuter tax applies. The federal government argued that the abolition is an integral part of the comprehensive master plan for fiscal consolidation. In particular, the difficult situation of the federal budget at the beginning of government in 2005 made it necessary to make significant cuts. Objective would be to the Government to submit a federal budget by 2011 without new debt. With the extra revenue from the abolition of the traveling allowance of around 2.5 billion euros could be saved.
This contrasts with that would benefit from the restoration of the commuter tax only about one-seventh of the taxpayer and the taxpayer. Especially those with low and middle-income commuters have never had the benefit of the old regime. Because most cases are already covered by the workers' standard amount of currently 920 €. For workers' lump sum in the income tax table has already been incorporated and therefore directly affects the income tax deduction of tax at source, according to the Federal Treasury. Nevertheless, the Federal Government under the new rules, a social-political component in the form of hardship provisions adopted for long-distance commuters for trips home for the disabled. So who take longer trips to work on the site must be able to deduct these trips under the new hardship provision for tax. Only for social reasons and because of the constitutionally required protection of marriage and family hardship provisions were attached. The legislature has always had the legitimate right to set certain limits. The "20-km limit" is based on a statistically derived rule.

third Situation of the commuters
The Federal Statistical Office has reported in a special evaluation in 2001, a worker in eastern Germany, on average 31.4 km and a West German employee travels 28.1 km. Also under the new law will benefit both still, the Federal Ministry of Finance on the Internet www.bmf.de. The limitation of the traveling allowance at distances from 20 Km means that the majority of commuters drive to their operation is no longer able to deduct as business expenses. The estimate of how many taxpayers have the new rules, a higher tax burden is difficult. The old system of full-time workers rose from about 12 km to work the employee lump sum and was therefore relevant to the industry without additional advertising costs from that to work. For employees with other professional expenses, but also for self- commuters and traders who have no lump sum was the (old) for travel to relevant starting at short distances to work. In a survey by the Federal Statistical Office in 2004 graduated from the total of 35.7 million, 30.3 million persons in employment as a professional commuters and commuters. 48.1% drove 10 miles to the workplace. 16.4% drove more than 25 miles to the workplace.

4th As it is in other countries?

In many countries, such as the USA, the UK and Greece, the cost of trips between home and work in general are not tax deductible. In Sweden, Finland, the Netherlands or Norway, the citizens in general only the cost of public transport claim.

5th Legal situation - before the Federal Constitutional Court

The League of Taxpayers on 01.12.2006 a test case brought against the Great of the coalition with the Tax Amendment Act 2007 adopted restrictions on the traveling allowance.

In the process it goes to the following facts: "A married applicant and appellant (plaintiff) obtained as a staff baker income from employment. He lives with his family in X and works in 70 km away Y. His wife also refers income from employment. According to the plaintiff, the distance between home and work place of his wife in the Z 37 km.

By its application for income tax reduction for the year 2007, the applicant, its spending on the way between home and work in the amount of € 4,620 as a deduction on the tax card to enter (220 days x 70 km x € 0.30) . The defendant and defendant in (the tax office - FA -) calculated the allowance according to the changed situation following the 2007 legislation reduced by 20 km (220 days x 50 km x 0,30 € = € 3,300 less Employee lump sum = 2 380 €). Against the negative decision by the extent of the wage tax reduction in 2007 the applicant lodged an unsuccessful appeal. "

the Bundesfinanzhof after several rulings by tax courts his doubts about the constitutionality of the new rules with its decision of 23 August 2007 (VI B 42/07) applied. Significant tax system and constitutional concerns in the literature, and conflicting decisions of the tax courts require a high court decision on this system. The Federal Constitutional Court has announced to negotiate in terms of commuters in the fall of 2008 in Karlsruhe. It is expected that the Federal Constitutional Court the deductibility of work-related travel expenses, net of income tax in principle, could support in principle. The introduction of factory gate principle with the exception for long-distance commuters will be by the Federal Constitutional Court with at least called into question.

6th The discussion - Pros and Cons for travel to

The Werktorprinzip
Another criticism of the new provisions that are allocated under the new law, the cost of travel between home and workplace privacy. The package is then no longer under the personal income tax as a Cost of earned income, the advertising costs, can be used. After this Interpretation begins the professional sphere - to achieve the employment income - only from the factory gate. Because the ride is led to and from work professionally, it would not apply if the work was abandoned. Where are divided opinions on this: Some experts believe that although the drive to work led occupation, the return trip, however, since it is the Privacy Act. Consequently, it is mixed costs. Mixing costs in terms of § 12 para II Income Tax Act does not generally deductible, but according to what BFH - verdict could lead to the expenses which the worker is on his way to work, are broken down by objective criteria (in this case 50% / 50%) and the jobs that portion of taxable income as business expenses as defined in § 9 of the Income Tax Act can be removed. The main argument of the tax courts is that the travel costs are necessary in order to generate revenue at all. The employee may not withdraw from these expenses. Journeys to work are in fact, with changing regulations, for more than 80 years recognized for tax purposes as a necessary expenditure. Thus said, the Federal Constitutional Court in 2002 from a basic decision of the German income tax law, the tax law's considerable sphere can not only be "at the factory gate" start.

supplement tax professionals and the Federal Finance Court, that the tax deduction for travel expenses to work for the purposes of taxation shall be assessed according to their performance. Which means that in the context of equal treatment of all taxpayers, the deductible cost of transporting the products of a company whose clients as essentially equated with the cost of transporting the goods to his customers work the same employer. The application of a package that appears here for simplicity as necessary. Even if it were not a subsidy, but advertising costs as an employee travel costs to the workplace often can not avoid, without ending the employment relationship.

scheme is contrary to the principle of economic efficiency

The new regulation is contrary to taxation under the principle of economic efficiency. For the determination of the chargeable income, in Germany, the objective net principle. This means that reduce all expenditures for the acquisition, conservation and preservation of earned income in the amount of the fee base.

When traveling allowance is not a subsidy, which the Federal Constitutional Court ruling of December 2002 on the deductibility of the cost of the double house leadership has agreed in principle, so the critics. The background is the equality for those who use, in principle, a company car for their occupational mobility can.

burden of income recipients

by the change of commuters are affected more than 11 million taxpayers. About 15.3% can not deduct more for trips between home and work, an appropriate fee. The immediate burden of many income recipients would be high. The long-distance commuters are affected by the waiver of the fee for the first 20 km.

Polluting Zersiedlungspauschale
is frequently mentioned in the discussion that removal package works as a polluting Zersiedlungspauschale. Lastly, the cheaper housing in the surrounding areas the increased costs compensate for the cost of mobility. Environmental organizations point out, however, that the removal fee, the discrepancy between home and workplace, fosters work ie inside the city and live in the countryside. In this context, the distance allowance sometimes referred to as "urban sprawl premium". Moreover, it is claimed that the state support of a shuttle service would cause problems of urban sprawl, in particular to a worsening of traffic problems in urban areas, the degradation of inner cities and suburban ghettos. Some even calling for the complete abolition. being criticized by others in turn that the traveling allowance Employees at a disadvantage, living consciously in the vicinity of their employer and take this higher rents in the purchase, but their rent can not deduct special tax, because cost of living (such as food, clothing, housing, etc.) over the basic allowance, currently € 7,664 (or € 15,328 for joint assessment) shall be settled. In contrast, argues that the high rents force in some large cities the workers to relocate their residence in the suburbs. For this situation, the commuters may not be punished. Some experts believe, however, the traveling allowance as a subsidy to be deleted, since the choice of place of residence was a private matter. Against the background the demand for subsidy reduction will require a reduction or abolition not only of the package, but rejected the tax deductibility of employee travel expenses as a whole. Economists say even favored an additional taxation of commuting, as commuting and social costs of transport to work productively and not wasted it.

reconciling work and family
the keyword protect marriage and family life is above all the hardship scheme for long-distance commuters and trips home ensure that the specificities and of dual marriages. The abolition promotes not so the incompatibility of marriage and Employment of spouses, the federal government. Which is opposed to infringements of the new rules against the constitutionally guaranteed protection of marriage and family, because two can get around in different places working spouse travel expenses for trips to the workplace by not only an apartment together.

The Labor calls for the flexibility of workers

create the same conditions state institutions which enhance rather than reduce commuting. Sun require the agencies to work flexibility in the choice of place of work, is in the planning of commercial areas in infrastructure and family needs often no consideration and the flexibility of the labor law (fixed-term contracts, temporary work), a growing number of workers live with it, changing every few years to have to work.

employers fear rising wage costs

employers who have historically strong focus on centralization fear a shortage of labor or an increase in the cost of labor. Economists look at such establishments is a real danger of the shift in foreign regions with a sufficient workforce.

7th Debate in the Bundestag

The Left on 25 September 2008 in a roll-call vote requested - by the Bundestag, the restoration of the old commuter tax, Bundestag printed matter 16/9167, 16/9569. Literally, in the complaint: ". With the application, the Federal Government asked to recognize the cost of paths between the home and workplace back completely as business expenses or business expenses"

The result of the vote was clearly hostile: were for the vote 450 deputies against the reintroduction. The representatives of the Union voted against the reintroduction of the old commuter tax, the SPD agreed to only one member of parliament from Baden-Württemberg for the flat rate.

The Greens rejected the old commuter tax to a few abstentions, also from. The 96 votes for the motion of the left are from the party itself, from the FDP and the deputies Scheer.

The Left had tried before the vote to persuade the members of the CSU to vote for the re-introduction, as they had during the election campaign in Bavaria also promoted a return to old fee.

"The factions of the CDU / CSU and SPD, he stressed during Committee deliberations to wait for their continued and firm position, the decision of the Constitutional Court to abolish the commuter tax, before any new decisions are made. Some courts did not, as sometimes represented, made it clear that the so-called factory gate principle could be designed in conformity with the Constitution. question which arose was the compatibility of the factory gate principle with the objective net principle of taxation and the height of a flat-rate payment of travel expenses. Only in this opinion could be adapted to build the scheme. If the Federal Constitutional Court to determine the incompatibility of legislation with the constitution, the taxpayers would it not be penalized because the retrospective account is secured by the provisional nature of the tax assessments ... The CSULandesgruppe stand for the full tax deductibility of expenses for trips between home and work . The Group of the SPD remembered because they speak to get it out since the fall of 2005, the commuter rate from the first kilometer. This was particularly the debates on the Tax Amendment Act 2007 made repeatedly clear. An alternative proposal would be revenue neutral, but ultimately the opposition of the CSU party
failed. "This is a quote from a meeting of the Advisory Committee.

8th What next?

The Federal Government is in the opinion of the Federal Constitutional Court charged if a new regulation that is consistent with the Constitution, promptly put into law on the way to ensure legal certainty.