Background: Legal and private health insurance, two competing systems
Only in the U.S. and Germany are competing today with the statutory health insurance and full private health insurance two different insurance systems together. Most recently in 2006, the Netherlands combined both offices. The Dutch have taken this decision because the juxtaposition brings a number of serious problems with it. The main difficulties lie in the differences in remuneration of providers and in the design of the contribution rates.
Contents
I. The basic principles of the competing systems
II, the transition to private health insurance was through the 2007 health reform more difficult
III. The basic rate in the private health insurance
IV History
I. The basic principles of the competing systems:
SHI:
The contributions are independent of health risk and raised depending on income. Children and non-working spouses are covered without any contribution. The contribution rate from 1 July 2009 14.9 percent.
PKV:
The private health insurance covered the following functions: acquisition of insurance coverage for such persons who are not insured by law, to aid claimants insurance benefits, which are not covered by the measure as part of medical expenses, comprehensive health insurance. Over insurance coverage for insured persons under the law a supplemental insurance to their individual needs as Einzellzimmerunterbringung to meet in-patient hospital and private medical treatment. The private health insurers calculate premiums on the basis of the health risk of the insured. The amount of the premium income is independent. Children and non-working spouses should be insured separately, they pay their own premiums.
just self-employed and insured with an income above the so-called compulsory insurance limit, which is nationwide in 2009 48.600/4.050, 00 EUR per year / per month, can switch to private health insurance. The change in private health insurance is particularly attractive for healthy singles with high income - they must have private health insurance or Risk premiums are charged, nor do they have to finance premiums for family members. For the chronically ill and families, a change in the private health insurance is less attractive.
The migration to the private health insurance of many young earners, the funding base of the SHI is weakened. For the financing of Solidarity in SHI is based on income solidarity, that is redistribution from people with high incomes to those with low income and risk solidarity, redistribution from the healthy to the sick.
Another important difference between the two systems lies in the different remuneration structures of the health care provider. This is particularly true for outpatient medical care. The doctor gets for legally insured person a mix of case fees and fee for service up to a ceiling amount in the form of the so-called volume control power.
for private patients receive the same doctor for-service payments without quantity limits. The financial incentives for doctors are clear, with privately insured patients can earn more money. Is frequently expressed by medical side that practices could only survive through the treatment of private patients, because the allowance by the statutory health insurance would no longer suffice.
the part of the statutory health insurance is often complained that they would have in comparison to private health insurance policyholders longer queuing to purchase and would get given less time for medical consultation. Experts find fault with the risk of over-supply of privately insured patients.
II, the transition to private health insurance was complicated by the 2007 health reform
The differences in the compensation system also lead to a sharp growth of expenditure in the private health insurance. This is one of the main causes of the ongoing rise in premiums in private health insurance. Because as mentioned in a previous post, is the last health reform in 2007 was reorganized that workers is made more difficult with an income above the limit for compulsory insurance is the change in the private health insurance full. In addition, on 1 April 2007, the modified standard rate and at 1 January 2009, the basic rate of private health insurance introduced. Under the new system, employees in three consecutive years to achieve an income above the limit for compulsory insurance to switch to private health insurance to full.
In 2007, net new addition to the PHI of 116 100 59 900 persons insured has almost halved. In 2008, net new business with 48 900 people continued to fall. For this group of people were also 18 900 not previously insured people. For private insurers, it could as long as those numbers should continue to write so come to significant premium increases for existing insured. This is particularly true for private health insurance companies that advertise low-cost calling plans offered to new customers seeking. Because these are healthy and well-earning new customers who want to get out of the solidarity system of statutory health insurance, dependent.
III. The basic rate in the private health insurance
With the introduction of the basic tariff in the private health insurance, the insurance obligation for the private health insurance attributable to group of people, officials say, self-employed workers with an income above the limit for compulsory insurance 1 January 2009 mandatory.
oriented service offering in the base fare on the list of services
health insurance. The premium may not exceed the maximum contribution in the GKV. Risk premiums may be levied. Deficits must be financed by the insured person during the normal rates. With the introduction of the basic tariff elements of risk solidarity in the private health insurance to take effect.
ask especially those with pre-existing conditions in the basic rate affordable insurance coverage for. According to the statements of the insurer would arise from this basic benefit expenditure in the base rate in nearly four-fold greater extent than by funding premiums would accrue. This leads to an industry-wide premium surcharge of just over one percent for the insured outside of the base rate. The influx of good risks in the private health insurance was full so difficult. Equal time was facilitated access for poor risks by the base rate.
still can not talk about a fair competition between health insurance systems. For the SHI system was still burdened by risk selection in favor of private health insurance. Similarly, the higher remuneration of the medical treatment of privately insured patients have remain unchanged, so some experts.
Fair competition between the two Systems is only possible under the same conditions. Conceivable, some experts would be an extension of risk adjustment on the private health insurance. Are more difficult, however, the adjustment of the financial incentives for preferential treatment of privately insured group. The revenue-neutral for the medical profession approximation of the compensation systems would pollute the GKV and PKV simultaneously relieve and aid support.
IV History
The establishment of health insurance for factory workers laid the foundation for our current health insurance system. On 17/01/1845 the creation of Prussia in the general trade regulation was approved. On 07/04/1876 then the relief funds were being treated uniformly, which is however limited initially to the medical and funeral services. The health insurance for workers was carried out as part of the social policy reforms on 6/15/1883, which were the persons to be insured, the insurance was compulsory, clearly mentioned. Saw the establishment of guilds, towns, community insurance, as well as company health and relief and miners' health insurance as a vehicle for social health insurance.
The health insurance were not available for many populations. For this reason, on a similar basis such facilities were established. This was for the first time a distinction between social and private health insurance, because in addition to the factory workers now also sought civil servants, teachers and clergy to access to private health insurance. From 1901 until then founded the private health insurance were placed under the supervision of office for private insurance. In the social insurance were self-employed craftsmen, unlike in the medieval guilds, not included. For this reason alone, followed by 25 chambers of trade calling to establish their health and benefit funds themselves.
began Increasingly insurance companies in the private health insurance to be actively courted primarily by officials. The period 1934-1937 was due to the law for the establishment of social security, and of the Regulations Governing the history of private health insurance particularly important one. From that time on, the spare cash as corporations under public law to public health insurance carriers. It was followed by a separation between workers and employees compensation fund. Members who were regarded as alien to social security was rejected. From this time they were responsible for the private health insurance.
The Second World War provided a turning point, as were banned in the Soviet zone of occupation private health insurance, which meant that in 1946 in the British zone, a meeting of health insurers was called. The meeting ended in 1947 with the decision to found an association of private health insurance for the British zone. In 1949, a nationwide association was established after that date were subject to all private health insurance legislation.
In 1970, this legislation means of the second health insurance ¬ amending law to a sustainable co-existence of the statutory insurance has helped. In 1989, the health reform law provided for a re-demarcation of private and publicly insured and it was the introduction of the standard fare in 1993. Contact for inquiries